By: gabriel sayegh via Medium.com
The inherent unfairness and cruelty of the cash bail system undermines the promise of safety, equal opportunity, and equal justice under law that New Yorkers cherish.
That’s why the pretrial laws the state legislature passed in 2019 — including bail reform — are so important.
The ever-worsening crises at Rikers and other jails across New York have magnified the significance of critical measures — including the 2019 bail reforms — that decarcerate, promote justice, and improve public safety. But now Governor Kathy Hochul has issued a proposal that would undermine bail reform (and other justice reforms). Groups across the state, including the Katal Center, are fighting back. To help readers better understand this fight, we examine the 2019 bail reform laws, the partial rollbacks of them in 2020, and what’s happening now.
Before bail reform was passed in 2019, jails were crowded with people who couldn’t afford to buy their freedom. About 23,000 people were detained in local jails across New York State — and even in early 2020, almost 70 percent of the people detained in New York City jails and nearly half of those in the state’s other jails were pretrial; they had not been convicted of a crime. They were locked up because they couldn’t afford bail. The overwhelming majority of those held in jails pretrial were Black and Latinx and poor. Though wealthier people accused of crimes could await trial in home confinement or with other restrictions, those who couldn’t afford cash bail frequently wound up at jails like the notorious Rikers Island simply because they couldn’t pay.
The tragic death of Kalief Browder in 2015 drove home the real-world consequences of criminalizing poverty and other entrenched racial disparities in our legal system. Kalief was a young Black man from the Bronx who was arrested at the age of 16 for the alleged theft of a backpack. His family could not afford the $3,000 bail set for him at his initial arraignment, so — like thousands of other New Yorkers — Kalief was sent to Rikers, where he remained for almost three years awaiting trial. He endured regular, almost unspeakable violence and numerous lengthy stays in solitary confinement.
The Bronx DA eventually dropped the charges and Kalief was released. But spending three years pretrial at Rikers caused him devastating harm. Kalief hanged himself when he was just 22 years old.
Kalief’s story forced the nation to bear witness once again to the violence-plagued Rikers Island jail complex and New York’s lethal bail system. His death spurred widespread calls for bail reform and to shut Rikers down.
The 2019 Justice Reforms
On April 1, 2019, after years of work by grassroots groups and advocates throughout New York, lawmakers in Albany passed a historic slate of criminal justice reform bills. As part of that legislation, bail reform accomplished several key objectives to advancing justice statewide:
1. The reforms eliminated money bail and pretrial detention for most New Yorkers facing misdemeanor and nonviolent felony criminal charges. This means that the majority of people charged with low-level offenses are not detained pretrial.
2. The legislation requires that most people are released on their own recognizance unless a judge rules that other conditions are necessary to assure court appearances.
3. The reforms restrict the use of electronic monitoring.
4. The legislation requires courts to consider an individual’s ability to pay before setting bail (for anyone who is still subject to bail).
Given New York’s unique pretrial laws, which prohibit the consideration of a finding of “dangerousness” in pretrial hearings, the 2019 reforms represented a substantial overhaul of the state’s pretrial system. Combined with changes in discovery practices passed in the same package, these reforms stand out nationwide in their transformation of pretrial practices. (For a more detailed explanation of the 2019 bail laws, see the Center for Court Innovation’s excellent resources.)
Discovery is the practice in which each party in a court case must turn over the evidence they intend to use at trial. But before the 2019 reforms, prosecutors in New York didn’t have to disclose evidence they had until the day a trial started, undermining the ability of the accused person to prepare. The state’s outdated and unfair discovery law contributed to delays in court processing times by denying people accused of crimes the critical materials needed to make informed decisions about their cases.
Bail Reform Implementation — and Blowback
As the new laws went into effect, the impact on jail populations was immediate: fewer people were imprisoned. The jail population in New York City alone dropped by more than 40 percent upon the law’s implementation.
But immediately after reforms passed, even before they went into effect, opponents called for repeal. The NYPD claimed that the crime rate was rising: it wasn’t. New York City pols and tabloids sensationalized stories about people who had been released without bail and rearrested.
Early in 2020, lawmakers reversed course, pushing measures to undermine bail reform. Community groups and other advocates fought against these changes, preventing the worst of the opposition’s proposals from passing. But lawmakers did make changes to the bail law — rolling back some of the reforms that advocates argued would lead to more unjust pretrial detention.
And that was exactly what happened. Even though there is no link between bail reform and increased crime — crime went down overall in 2020 — the blowback has been substantial. Some law enforcement officials, including the NYPD commissioner, have been caught lying publicly about bail reform and continue to misinform the public.
As predicted, the bail-reform rollbacks have sent more people to jail pretrial, making it that much harder to close not only Rikers, but other deadly jails throughout the state.
Earlier this month, in response to the racist fearmongering and misinformation put forth by the opposition, Governor Hochul issued a “public safety” proposal that would undermine major criminal justice reforms and lead to more people being jailed pretrial. Katal, other community and advocacy groups, and public defenders from across the state are organizing to stop the proposed rollbacks.
It is wrong to hold people in jail simply because they cannot pay bail. It is racist to detain mostly Black and Latinx people at Rikers and other jails while wealthier (and mostly white) defendants can pay their way to freedom. Elected officials are also speaking out against rollbacks. In a new analysis about bail reform, released on March 22, New York City Comptroller Brad Lander has called for state legislators to “reject rollbacks and instead strengthen implementation” of the bail reform laws.
Lawmakers must reject these destructive rollback proposals and make sure that judges follow the law in their pursuit of justice. To do otherwise will further corrode public safety and trust, continuing to pervert the legal system and use it as another tool of oppression rather than one of redress.